Plastic box or cardboard box: which is best for your business cards?
Printers and companies often hesitate between a plastic box and a cardboard box for packing business cards. Both have their place. Here is a point-by-point comparison, including the cases where cardboard is enough.
Plastic or cardboard: the comparison
| Criterion | Plastic box | Cardboard box |
|---|---|---|
| Protection | Rigid and closed: protects against crushing and damp | Enough when cards are handed over in person; crushes and dislikes water |
| Presentation | The top card shows through the box | Opaque, but can be printed in your colours |
| Reuse | Serves as storage for years | Loses its shape with use, rarely kept |
| Packing | Ready to use: open, fill, close | Delivered flat: has to be folded before filling |
| Recycling | Polypropylene and polystyrene are recyclable | Recycled with paper and card |
| Branding | By the visible card; the box is not printed | Logo and colours printed on the box |
Protection: what a box of business cards goes through
Between the print shop and the customer's desk, a box of cards is stacked, shipped and sometimes crushed at the bottom of a parcel. A rigid plastic box keeps its shape and holds the cards flat, away from damp. Crystal polystyrene remains brittle if it is knocked; translucent polypropylene and our shockproof material withstand drops. Cardboard absorbs small knocks, but it crushes and dislikes water: it needs more padding in the parcel.
Presentation: seeing the cards without opening the box
A clear box shows the top card: the customer recognises the order at a glance and the printer's work is on show. In a stock room, each box can be identified without opening or labelling it. Cardboard is opaque, but it can be printed, and that is its real advantage: a box in the printer's or the company's colours carries a brand. Our boxes are not printed.
Reuse and recycling
A plastic box stays with the customer: it stores the cards down to the last one, and then something else. Our polypropylene (PP) and polystyrene (PS) boxes are recyclable, and polypropylene is commonly accepted in household recycling. Our shockproof material usually has no recycling stream of its own: it is above all a box that gets reused. Cardboard is recycled with paper; on the other hand, it is rarely reused.
Packing time: the difference that counts in the print shop
A cardboard box usually arrives flat: it has to be folded, sometimes glued or tucked together, before the cards go in. A plastic box arrives ready: open it, drop in the pack of cards, close it. On one order the difference is tiny. Over dozens of orders a day, a plastic box is much quicker to fill, and that time matters as much as the price of the packaging.
Price per box: compare the full cost
Per unit, a standard cardboard box may cost less than a plastic one. The sums change once you add folding time, padding in the parcel and replacing cards damaged in transit. Our prices are public and decrease with quantity, from the mini pack to the pallet: see prices.
When cardboard is enough, and when it is the better choice
- The cards are handed over in person, with no shipping.
- The packaging has to carry your brand: logo, colours, a printed message.
- The customer is not expected to keep the box.
In the other cases – parcels, premium cards, customers who keep the box on their desk – plastic gives protection and presentation that cardboard does not.
Try it with your own cards
The most objective way is to compare the real thing. Ask for our free sample kit, reserved for businesses: fill the boxes with your cards, time the packing, drop them, then compare with your current packaging. Do you pack cards every day? Our page for printers and web-to-print sets out the sizes in stock and the terms for large volumes.
FAQ
Are plastic business card boxes recyclable?
Our polypropylene (translucent) and polystyrene (crystal) boxes are recyclable. Polypropylene is commonly accepted in household recycling; the rules vary from one local authority to another.
Does a plastic box cost more than a cardboard box?
Per unit, it may cost a little more. But it is filled without folding, needs less padding and protects the cards better in transit: compare the full cost. Our prices are shown on the site.
Can a plastic box be customised?
Our boxes are not printed: the top card, visible through the box, identifies the order. Coloured boxes can be made on request, above a minimum quantity.